-
Made in and the substantial working: the point of view of European Court of Justice
The European Court of Justice in its judgment C-Case C‑210/22 released on 21 September 2023 declares that, in the determination of the made in, apart the type of rule of origin for non-preferential origin calculation, it is important to check if a substantial transformation has been performed . Indeed, processing or working operations may still be substantial when that processing or working brings a clear qualitative change to the product. This a very interesting judgement that can provide support in the ongoing management of the AEO. The European legal framework is made by the following pillars: the Guidance on non-preferential rules of origin (March 2022) TAXUD; the regulations currently in force…
-
CBAM and made in: some explanations
CBAM (carbon border adjustment mechanism) obligations require the good knowledge of the non-preferential origin. The first questions that can arise is: what is “non-preferential origin” or “made in”? The non-preferential origin is the economic nationality of a good; for istance: “made in EU, made USA”. In other words, the mentioned status is obtained where goods are “wholly obtained” in one country or, when two or more countries are involved in the manufacture of a product, origin is obtained where goods underwent their last, substantial, economically-justified processing or working, in an undertaking equipped for that purpose, resulting in the manufacture of a new product or representing an important stage of manufacture.…